Man shot, killed in domestic dispute was professional bull rider competing at Utah State Fair

Demetrius Allen, the man who was shot and killed in a domestic assault in Salt Lake City late Sept. 11 or early Sept. 12 of 2022, was a professional bull rider who performed under the name Ouncie Mitchell. Photo:

SALT LAKE CITY, Utah, Sept. 12, 2022 (Gephardt Daily) — Demetrius Allen, the 27-year-old man fatally shot in a domestic assault case overnight in the Ballpark neighborhood of Salt Lake City, was a professional bull rider whose stage name was Ouncie Mitchell.

Allen was in Utah to compete at the Utah State Fair, and had arranged to stay at the apartment of a former girlfriend, LaShawn Bagley, who has been charged with Allen’s murder.

Allen, a Texas native, was ranked 157th in the world in 2022, according to the Professional Bull Riders web page for Ouncie Mitchell.

Sam Gleason, commissioner of Professional Bull Riders, released a statement early Monday afternoon:

We are shocked and saddened to learn of the passing last night of Demetrius Allen, who fans best knew as Ouncie Mitchell, in Salt Lake City. Ouncie was a talented cowboy and a familiar face on the Velocity Tour. He also competed — and won — in the Bill Pickett Invitational Rodeo, whose president Valeria Howard-Cunningham shares our grief.

Ouncie got his name because he was born small. He grew up to compete with a huge heart. The PBR organization sincerely extends our own heartfelt condolences to Ouncie’s cousin Ezekiel Mitchell and the entire Mitchell family.

Demetrius Allen, also known as professional Bull Rider Ouncie Mitchell. Photo: Sean Gleason/Facebook

Shooting arrest

Suspected shooter LaShawn Denise Bagley, 21, was booked into jail at 9:50 a.m. Monday on suspicion of:

  • Murder, a first-degree felony
  • Felony discharge of a firearm, a third-degree felony

Salt Lake City police identified the man shot and killed as Demetrius Omar Lateef Allen, 27.

Salt Lake City Police responded after a 12:06 a.m. Monday call to dispatch regarding a shooting. Upon arriving at 965 S. 200 West, in the Ballpark neighborhood of Salt Lake City, officers found a man, later identified as Allen, with a gunshot wound to his torso in the parking lot outside an apartment.

Officers observed several bullet impacts/strikes to exterior windows/doors of the apartment, with shots appearing to have come from inside the apartment, the statement says.

“The male victim was transported to IMC Hospital where he was later pronounced deceased.”

Bagley, the apartment resident, had been allowing the victim to stay with her “while he was in town for the rodeo at the State Fair grounds,” the probable cause statement says. “The A/P (arrested person) and the victim have been previously involved in an on-and-off romantic relationship together.”

According to the statement, Bagley, Allen, and a witness traveled to the State Fair and afterward went together to a bar in the downtown area.

While outside the bar, the statement continues, a verbal altercation took place between Allen and Bagley. Bagley then left in her vehicle, and Allen and the witness got a ride back to Bagley’s apartment to retrieve Allen’s property, which was inside the apartment.

“Before arriving at the apartment, the victim attempted phone calls and text messages to alert the suspect that he was coming over to retrieve his property,” the police statement says.

When Allen arrived at the apartment, he knocked on the door and stated he was there to retrieve his property, charging documents say.

Bagley then “fired several rounds through the glass door with at least one round striking the victim in the torso where he fell to the ground.”

Police found no indication that Allen had attempted to force entry into the apartment, the statement says. A witness also told police “there was no entry or attempted forced entry into the apartment and that they were only there to retrieve the victim’s property so the victim could leave and stay at another residence.”

Arriving officers saw Allen outside the apartment’s exterior door, unable to move, and “developed a plan to move the victim away from the exterior apartment door in order to safely render aid,” the statement says. No observable blood evidence was found inside the apartment unit.

Bagley had a strong odor of alcohol on her breath when taken into custody, the statement says. Post Miranda, she declined to be interviewed by police.

Bagley has lived in Utah, Texas and Michigan in the past year, and officials believe she is a possible flight risk. A judge ordered that Bagley be held without bail.

Police on the scene of a fatal shooting near 900 South 200 West. Photo: Gephardt Daily/Doug Flagler


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here