Update: ‘Cold case’ murder suspect extradited to Utah after charged with, confessed to 1977 killing of Utah teen

Patrick Michael McCabe. Photo Courtesy: Salt Lake County

SALT LAKE CITY, Utah, March 6, 2017 (Gephardt Daily) — Patrick Michael McCabe, charged in the 1977 murder of 16-year-old Sharon Schollmeyer, was extradited from Florida to Utah over the weekend to face charges.

Sim Gill, Salt Lake County District Attorney, on Friday filed one count of murder in the first degree, one count of aggravated burglary, and one count of aggravated sexual assault, in what had previously been a “cold case,” which moved forward after a DNA match was found.

“(The) charges and this arrest are a significant step towards justice for the alleged victim, her family and the community in this nearly 40-year-old case,” said a statement from Gill’s office, adding that suspects are presumed innocent until found guilty in a court of law.

The District Attorney’s Office alleges that McCabe broke into Schollmeyer’s home, tied her up, raped her and killed her.

According to a probable cause statement, police were called to Schollmeyer’s apartment on Dec. 5, 1977, and found her nude body in the bathtub. Her halter top had been used to gag her, and a scarf was tied around her head, covering her eyes and nose. Pieces of rope and nylon stockings were found in the tub, which also contained about six inches inches of water. A butcher knife lay nearby, on the bath mat.

Schollmeyer’s mother, Sally Kadleck, had gone to her daughter’s apartment after learning the teen had not reported for work. She was let into her daughter’s apartment by the then building manager.

Police investigated with the tools they had at the time, which did not include DNA technology. The case went cold, waiting for science to catch up.

STORIES OF INTEREST
Pres. Trump signs executive order to review status of Utah's Bears Ears, other national monuments

In September 2013, DNA from the recovered halter top was matched to an unknown DNA sample, according to the probable cause statement. In December 2016, the sample was matched to one from McCabe, now 59, who most recently resided in Bell, Fla.

The probable cause statement indicates that earlier this month, McCabe was read his Miranda rights, then admitted to using his key to enter Schollmeyer’s apartment, where he went to her bedroom and found her asleep. He used the knife to make the teenager cooperate, McCabe said, then he tied her up, raped her, took her to the tub, then strangled her and held her head underwater.

McCabe said he left the state five months later, and except for a single overnight visit, he never returned to Utah.

McCabe was arrested by Salt Lake City Police officers and local law enforcement officials in Florida, where he had served prison time in 1999 for a sexual offense against a minor.

First-degree murder is a capital offense, punishable by death. Aggravated burglary and aggravated sexual assault are both first-degree felonies, each punishable by up to life in prison.

Sharon Schollmeyers. Photo: Salt Lake City Police Department

2 COMMENTS

  1. Can someone just check to see if this guy was still managing those apartments 11 months later in November 1978 when a 2nd murder occurred at the same apartment!

  2. It would seem plausible that he had a copy of the apartment key and made a return trip back to Utah to strike again. The police should investigate this as a second murder and put him to death if found guilty. You can’t trust a word this man says.

LEAVE A REPLY